Over the past couple of weeks, The Oregonian has been asking its readers to pick an all-decade Oregon State football team. As you can imagine, it’s a tough task. So many notable names that bring back so many notable memories.
I’m here to try and set the record straight. Just who should be on the OSU all-decade team?
My offensive/special
teams selections:
Quarterback
Nominees: Jonathan Smith, Derek Anderson, Matt Moore, Sean Canfield
Given that three of the four are currently on NFL rosters (all but Smith), quarterback is a position that’s been fairly good to the Beavers this past decade. However, it feels like quarterback is a position that’s reviewed fairly critically in Corvallis; of the four, the fans at Reser wanted three (to my memory) replaced at some point in their career. Anderson made too many bone-headed decisions, Moore (a transfer from UCLA) threw 19 interceptions to just 11 touchdowns in his first of two seasons, and Canfield never really won over OSU fans until halfway through his first-team All-Conference senior season. Smith never really faced the same criticism as the other three. Maybe it’s because he was a walk-on. Maybe it’s because Oregon State fans hadn’t been spoiled with recent success, and expectations weren’t as high. It’s not like Smith wowed people – he was named honorable mention All-Conference as a junior and a senior. But he was named MVP of the Fiesta Bowl. Uh, not too shabby. Give me one quarterback to win one game, give me Smith.
My pick: Jonathan Smith
Oregonian readers pick: Jonathan Smith (51%)
Running back
Nominees: Ken Simonton, Steven Jackson, Yvenson Bernard, Jacquizz Rodgers
Wow. Good luck deciding between those four. Simonton was a huge part of the Fiesta Bowl team, and was touted as a preseason Heisman candidate in 2001. Jackson is the only one to have success in the NFL, and was twice named third-team All-American at OSU. However, he turned pro after his junior season and didn’t give himself that extra year to cement himself as the greatest running back in OSU history. Bernard had three great years in an Oregon State uniform, and although there’s nothing wrong with consistency, Bernard never really possessed that jaw-dropping, game-breaking ability that lands running backs on highlight reels. But Jacquizz Rodgers, the final and most recent nominee, has been consistent and flashy and has caught the attention of the nation after just two seasons. When it’s all said and done (assuming he sticks around as a senior), Rodgers will have surely shattered almost every running back record in Corvallis. Not to mention, he’s helped put Oregon State on the brink of the Rose Bowl twice already, and produced the greatest single game performance (186 yards in the 27-21 win over No. 1 USC) of the decade.
My pick: Jacquizz Rodgers
Oregonian readers pick: Steven Jackson (45%)
Wide receivers
Nominees: T.J. Houshman-dzadeh, Chad Johnson, James Newson, Mike Hass, Sammie Stroughter, James Rodgers
Another talented group. Another tough decision. All six have a special place in my orange and black heart, so this one was especially tough for me. Johnson didn’t put up spectacular numbers in his one season in Corvallis, but he is – by far – the most well-known of the six. Whether that be because of his antics off the field or his recent name change, it doesn’t matter. But he did (sort of) bash on Corvallis in his book “What Football and Life Have Thrown My Way,” and his stay in Corvallis was very, very short. “Housh” has had a fairly successful career in the NFL as well, but, like Chad, he wasn’t here for very long, and he did help screw up fantasy football season last season. So although I love the fact that those two helped OSU to an 11-1 season in 2000, I can’t name them all-decade. Many of you may not remember Newson – he hasn’t had success at the next level-but he did earn All-Conference recognition three times, and was without a doubt my favorite Beaver in the first half of the decade. If it wasn’t for the immense talent that followed him, Newson would have easily earned all-decade honors in my book. But then came Hass, Stroughter, and the older Rodgers. Hass, the recipient of the 2005 Belitnikoff award, which goes to the nation’s top receiver, has to make the all-decade team. He put up incredible numbers, and won an award that none of the others even sniffed. Stroughter gets my nod just because he’s arguably the most beloved Beaver of the decade. And because he was pretty dang successful. And because, well, he was my favorite Beaver of the decade. That leaves out Rodgers, who has had three pretty successful years himself in Corvallis, but still has one more year to prove himself as an all-decade receiver.
My pick: Hass and Strougher
Oregonian readers pick: Hass (64%) and Stroughter (12%)
Other offensive/special
teams positions:
Tight end
Nominees: Martin Maurer, Tim Euhus, Joe Newton
My pick: Joe Newton
Oregonian readers pick: Joe Newton (64%)
Offensive line
Nominees: Kyle DeVan, Gregg Peat, Matt Brock, Chris Gibson, Adam Koets, Doug Nienhuis, Andy Levitre, Adam Speer, Roy Schuening, Jeremy Perry
My pick: Andy Levitre, Roy Scheuning, Kyle DeVan, Chris Gibson, Jeremy Perry
Oregonian readers pick: Andy Levitre (24.3%), Roy Scheuning (17.3%), Matt Brock (16.1%), Kyle DeVan (10.3%), Jeremy Perry (8.3%)
Punter
Nominees: Carl Tobey, Sam Paulescu, Johnny Hekker
My pick: Sam Paulescu
Oregonian readers pick: Sam Paulescu (71%)
Kicker
Nominees: Alexis Serna, Ryan Cesca, Justin Kahut, Kirk Yliniemi
My pick: Alexis Serna
Oregonian poll pick: Alexis Serna (81%)
Kick returner
Nominees: Lamar Herron, Gerard Lawson, James Rodgers
My pick: James Rodgers
Oregonian readers pick: James Rodgers (85%)
Punt returner
Nominees: Hint… there’s only one.
My pick: Uh, do I even need to say?
Oregonian readers pick: Sammie, Sammie, Sammie!!! (100%)
Tune in next week for my all-decade defensive team selections.