Editorial: Silence from Jacobs

By The Independent Collegian Editorial Board

As President of U. Toledo, it is Lloyd Jacobs’ responsibility to maintain a channel of communication with the UT community regarding the state of our institution and his performance as its head administrator.

We members of the IC staff have been frustrated in our recent attempts to open a dialogue with Jacobs regarding the Faculty Senate’s review of his performance. As the foremost source for news regarding the UT community, it is our right and responsibility to bring to light any issues, be they positive or negative, regarding the decision-makers in control of our tuition funds and taxpayer dollars.

To clarify, the IC does not hold an anti-administration or anti-Jacobs stance; we seek to discuss all sides of any issue, giving those involved the opportunity to present and defend their position. We requested an interview with Jacobs at the end of June, several weeks after the review was published. It was not until July 9th that a one-paragraph email response was made via Jacobs’ secretary.

“Everybody needs feedback. I am appreciative. The problem however with these assessments is that they tend to focus on people: me, the provost or the board; when what we really need is conversation about our pursuit of excellence. It seems imperative to me that we engage in a discussion of how we make the university and the world a better place, and focus less on individuals.”

This brief cop-out does nothing to further the conversation about the excellence of our university. As the public figurehead and highest-paid member of this administration, Jacobs serves a specific, individual role and should be viewed as an individual. Our pursuit of excellence requires that we evaluate the effectiveness of those receiving large salaries to govern our school. Students provide the funds to employ the President and other administrators; without assessments like this, how are we to judge whether or not he is fulfilling his responsibilities adequately?

It is August now, and we still await the interview we deserve. What does this silence from the administration represent? By refusing to challenge the claims of the performance review, Jacobs only gives more credence to the criticisms made of him, one of which targeted his weakness in communication with the community. Given the harsh judgment of Jacobs’ performance laid out in the Faculty Senate’s review, it is shocking that he has not made any attempt to deny the claims made against him. It would serve him better to offer evidence that his performance is not as poor as the review claims, rather than the weak attempt to completely dodge the issue offered by his email response.

We have delayed publishing a story on the Faculty Senate’s performance review so as not to present a one-sided account. It is our sincere hope that President Jacobs will understand our intent: not to jump on the bandwagon in criticizing him, but to provide him an opportunity to present his side.

Read more here: http://www.independentcollegian.com/forum/silence-from-jacobs-1.2283359
Copyright 2026