Column: Black is still just Black

By Mark Carter

A few weeks ago, I was in line at my favorite burger joint, Five Guys, and I heard a peculiar conservation taking place next to me. Two guys were casually discussing same-sex marriage and President Obama, but it was one simple statement that sparked my attention and motivated me to write this column. One of the guys said “Gay is totally the new black. People like Perez Hilton and Rosie O’Donnell are no different than Martin Luther King Jr. and Medgar Evers.”

A statement like that was not only ignorant but an absurdly poor comparison, in my opinion. As I received my cheeseburger, I could not help but think that the two guys would have probably been less offensive to me if they had referred to President Obama and myself as the ‘n’ word rather than comparing the martyrs of the Civil Rights Movement to a couple of celebrities who happen to be homosexual. Dr. King was murdered because of the color of his skin. Medgar Evers was murdered because of the color of his skin. These two men were not martyred because of who they preferred sexually.

We in the Black community have heard this kind of comparison before. In 2004, gay marriage supporters tried to combine the movement with the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950’s and 1960’s and it backfired. In Ohio that year, polls found that nearly sixty percent of African-American voters supported the gay marriage amendment to the state Constitution. In 2008 during the Proposition 8 fight in California, many in the Black community joined with conservatives to ban gay marriage, in part as a response to many adopting the “gay is the new Black” rallying cry.

I will always contend that marriage should stay between a man and a woman. There is a stark contrast between discrimination and protection of sacred values and traditions. I supported the “Matthew Shephard Act” that President Obama signed into law just this past year. The murder of that young man twelve years ago still shakes me to my core. On the flip side, I support the Defense of Marriage Act, which was passed in 1996. Conservative to moderate states in the Midwest should not have to recognize the more liberal marriage laws of California and Massachusetts.

I believe it is very important for children in this day and age to have the structure and discipline of a home with a mother and a father. Same-sex marriage only adds to the constant erosion of the traditional family unit that I and so many other Americans are raised in and hope to establish in our futures. We have to put our foot down somewhere or the generation of Jersey Shore, sagging pants, and perpetual apathy will become the lost generation.

My point in all of this is homosexuals in this country will not gain African Americans as an ally in their fight for marriage equality by making statements like the gentlemen at Five Guys. Statements like that exploits the struggles and suffering of generations of African Americans who fought and died so that I can write this column and attend the University of Toledo. Until we can sit down and have meaningful dialogue on what the priority is for all races, ethnicities, religions, sexual preferences and genders, we are simply; in the words of James Brown, “Talkin Loud and Saying Nothing”. The simple fact is Black is still and will forever be just Black, but there are ways that the gay community can win over other minorities in their fight for equal rights.

President Kennedy made an argument that puts this debate into perspective when articulating the U.S./Soviet relationship: “Our most basic common link is that we all inhabit this small planet. We all breathe the same air. We all cherish our children’s future. And we are all mortal.” The gay community has a potential ally in the Black community but they have to pursue that relationship in a compassionate and constructive way. The only way to win us over is to appeal to us as humans and citizens of this great country, and not as just African Americans.

— Mark Carter is a U. Toledo senior majoring in political science

Read more here: http://www.independentcollegian.com/forum/black-is-still-just-black-1.2283366
Copyright 2026 The Independent Collegian