Last week, as our government struggled with legislation meant to hold financial corporations accountable, a big American corporation announced plans to help keep governments accountable.
Google’s new “Government Tracker” tool may be an unprecedented initiative by a for-profit company, one that pressures governments to be more transparent in their information gathering. With some caveats, it makes public the number of requests Google gets from the world’s governments to release and censor data.
For the first half-year of data, the United States trails only Brazil in the numbers; the U.S. government requested data from Google 3,580 times between July and December 2009. In requests for data removal, the U.S. weighs in at a distant fourth, with 123 requests.
But the public might ask: Why? What’s in it for Google? The company’s official mission is “to organize the world’s information and make it universally accessible and useful.” It’s up for debate whether this goal is benevolent, sinister, or both; but it’s certain that Google makes a tidy profit from it. If we accept the old adage that knowledge is power, too, then their mission makes Google very powerful indeed.
Many large companies, though, from Nike to Bank of America, are trying ostensibly to do a little good in the world — a phenomenon that’s being called the “new corporate philanthropy.” According to Google.org, the search company’s “philanthropic wing,” they “have set a goal of devoting 1% of Google’s equity and yearly profits to philanthropy.”
Of course, no company is perfect, and that includes Google. Making the world’s information public is a great principle when applied to governments, but it’s more problematic when applied to copyrighted published works, say, or private citizens. The company has faced numerous lawsuits over its quest to scan the world’s books, for example, and Google has also been criticized for being complicit in government censorship in China and elsewhere. Most recently, Google’s mapping project sparked controversy in Germany when it was revealed their “streetview” cars were also scanning for home Wi-Fi networks without prior permission.
Then there is the matter of compliance with government requests for information or removal — Google’s new government tracker omits this data from their service, though they comment, “We would like to be able to share more information…but it’s not an easy matter.” Transparency seldom goes all the way, it turns out.
Still, as Goldmann Sachs writhes under ongoing public scrutiny and BP’s oil spill burns its way across the Gulf of Mexico, it is heartening to see a company doing something, anything, that’s not directly beneficial to its bottom line.