Oil spill prompts new course option

By Zach Geiger

The week following the Gulf oil spill, Penn State professor Timothy Bralower was sitting in a restaurant in Houston, Texas.

As news of the spill began to dominate the media, Bralower said the attitude in the bar was much different.

“Nobody was talking about it,” said Bralower, head of Penn State Geosciences. “It was a very surreal environment for me.”

Bralower couldn’t stop thinking about it, so he reached out to Nancy Tuana, director of Penn State’s Philosophy Graduate Studies program.

The result? New Schreyer Honors College course Earth 297H, (The 2010 Gulf Oil Spill: Science and Ethics of a Natural Catastrophe).

“The idea is to present all of the conflicts around deep-water drilling and oil exploration in general,” Bralower said.

The course is designed to be a comprehensive approach to the situation, he said.

Bralower said he’ll tackle the scientific aspect of the issue while Tuana will focus on the complex social issues including corporate responsibility and socioeconomic aspects.

Students enrolled in Earth 297H won’t just be sitting in a classroom all semester — they will have the opportunity to witness the devastation first-hand.

A planned trip to the Gulf of Mexico will allow the students to tour the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina and hopefully examine the Gulf beaches and wetland ecosystems affected by the spill, Bralower said.

“We’ll make every effort to get us close to the oil,” he said.

The students will also work with Shell to learn more about deepwater drilling, Bralower said. Working with Shell will hopefully dispel the myth that oil companies are reckless, he said.

“These companies have incredible safety procedures,” he said. “We want to show how a major oil company explores in deepwater.”

Guest lecturers may be called in to discuss BP’s financial situation and the economics of the disaster. Marine biologists and petroleum engineers are also on the list of potential guest lecturers, Bralower said.

“The issues are very complicated,” Bralower said. “It’s hard to paint a black and white picture here.”

If students do make it to the oil-covered beaches of the Gulf, the devastation that they see is likely to remain long after the course ends.

The severity and long-term impacts of the April 20 oil spill are still unknown, said Anil Kulkarni, who studies combustion and fluid mechanics and is a Penn State professor of mechanical engineering.

Though not involved in the Earth 297H course or the Gulf cleanup efforts, Kulkarni described the cleanup situation in the Gulf as “hopeless” in part because of thick oil in the water.

“It’s like mayonnaise,” Kulkarni said. “Whenever it sticks to something, it’s finished.”

When oil and water mix, they become emulsified, Kulkarni said. The effects can be damaging to humans and animals alike.

“We have a spill that is ten times the size of the last big oil spill of the Exxon-Valdez in Prince William Sound,” Kulkarni said.

Though cleanup is underway, it will be a long-term struggle even after the oil well is permanently capped, Kulkarni said. The effects of the oil dispersants being used to break up the oil and the potential for tropical storms in the Gulf also pose an unknown threat, Kulkarni said.

Discussing those threats — and how to prevent them in the future — is the entire purpose of creating the course for the fall semester, Bralower said.

“We’re just at the beginning of what happens in the Gulf,” he said.

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/08/04/oil_spill_prompts_new_course_o.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian