No verdict reached in Sandusky case, deliberations to continue Friday

By Mindy Szkaradnik and Rachel White

Jurors began deliberating about the Jerry Sandusky case shortly after 1 p.m. on the eighth day of the trial and did not reach a verdict by the time deliberations ended about eight hours later Thursday night.

A court alert sent at about 9:40 p.m. indicated that deliberations ended for the night and would reconvene at 9 a.m. Friday.

In his closing statement to the jury, Joe Amendola argued that much of the evidence presented in the case does not “add up.”

He argued that there was a conspiracy between the people who reported Sandusky sexually abused children – including the boys who said they were abused.

Amendola made it clear to the jury that it is their “recollection” of what occurred during the trial that will ultimately result in a verdict of guilty or not guilty.

Amendola said the commonwealth decided early on in the case that Sandusky was guilty. To support his theory, Amendola referred to the recording of Corporal Joseph Leiter, Trooper Scott Rossman and Ben Andreozzi in which they told the person referred to as “Victim 4” about the other statements they gathered. He said that the commonwealth “screwed up.”

Amendola said that the commonwealth interviewed the men who said they were abused by Sandusky multiple times until the men told officials what they wanted to hear.

He said that if prosecutors really thought that Sandusky was the “monster” that they presented him to be, that they would have arrested him in 2008 when the first allegation was made and would have not left him a free man.

Amendola said the only reason that the commonwealth did not arrest Sandusky was because they did not have enough evidence to convict him until after they “coached” the witnesses who testified in this case.

In addition, Amendola said it does not make sense that the first allegation against Sandusky happened in the mid 1990s.

“Out of the blue, when he was in his mid 50’s, he decided to become a pedophile,” Amendola said.

Amendola said the jury has to believe that Sandusky was having relationships with all of the alleged victims during the same timeframe.

Many of the men who said they were abused by Sandusky testified that they spent time with Sandusky in his home during the same years that others

Amendola also rehashed Sandusky’s November 2011 interview with Bob Costas. In his statement, Amendola said Sandusky has a habit of repeating questions asked to him before he answers them, as he did in the interview.

Citing testimony from a former Penn State coach that Sandusky was seen bringing young boys to the shower and noting that he was often seen with children otherwise, Amendola said Sandusky would be the “boldest perpetrator in history” if he actually committed the crimes.

Also, Amendola said he would be the first to say, “If [Sandusky] did this, he should rot in jail his entire life.”

“Regardless of the outcome, this is awful,” Amendola said.

Before wrapping up his closing argument, Amendola read Mother Teresa’s “Anyway” Poem, at Sandusky’s request.

“I’m asking you to return the verdict of not guilty,” Amendola said. “Mr. Sandusky will never get his life back, it is impossible.”

After Amendola finished his final argument and court took a recess and then went back in session so the Commonwealth could argue for the final time as to why the jury should find Sandusky guilty.

As some of the men who testified they were abused by Jerry Sandusky sat in the courtroom and listened, prosecutor Joe McGettigan gave his closing arguments in the former defensive coordinator’s trial claiming there was no conspiracy between anyone in accusing Sandusky of sexual abuse.

“Its not about conspiracies…It’s not about fame, or fortune, or money,” McGettigan said.

For the conspiracy theory to be true, many people would have had to be corrupt, McGettigan said, including himself, the grand jury, Mike McQueary, police officers and the men who reported they were abused.

“I don’t think troopers get raises for doing their jobs,” McGettigan said to jurors.

He also said if there was a conspiracy that caused the charges to be brought against Sandusky, there would have had to have been “time travel” involved because some of the men reported Sandusky abused them in the early 90s, though he was not charged until 2012.

In his closing arguments, McGettigan also pointed out to jurors that Sandusky’s attorney never asked any of the witnesses about the specific offenses they said occurred to them – he only asked questions about dates and places and car colors.

McGettigan told jurors that many people who testify about sexual abuse go through various emotions, including nervousness.

The man called “Victim 1” had difficulty speaking about the alleged sexual offenses that occurred to him because of the “tremendous emotional response” that he had of the recollection of the incidents, McGettigan said.

He said the people who testified about the alleged abuse that occurred to them knew they were going to be called liars when they testified about it. McGettigan also apologized about asking the men who testified recall the details about the abuse they said they endured, as he did in his opening argument.

Many of the men who reported Sandusky abused them had behavioral problems or family issues. McGettigan said Sandusky was “preying” on the boys who were the “most vulnerable.”

Throughout his closing argument, McGetttigan called Sandusky a “predatory pedophile” multiple times.

Sandusky had access to a “pool of vulnerable victims” through his charity, The Second Mile, McGettigan said. He said Sandusky was able to find biographical data easily, such as phone numbers, addresses and information about their family situations.

Also during his closing statement, McGettigan made light of Sandusky’s interview with Bob Costas. McGettigan said if someone were to ask him if we were a pedophile, as Costas asked Sandusky, his immediate response would be “You’re crazy.”

McGettigan also said the tape that was played for jurors of a conversation between the man called McGettigan said while pointing to Sandusky. “Acknowledge it and give [the people who said they were abused by him] justice and give [Sandusky] the justice he really deserves.”

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2012/06/21/no_verdict_reached_in_sandusky_case_deliberations_to_continue_friday.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian