When conservative blogger Andrew Breitbart posted the two-minute edited video of a speech given by Shirley Sherrod, his intent was to show that the NAACP tolerated reverse racism in its ranks. How could the oldest civil-rights organization single out the Tea Party for racism when it too had racist elements? What ensued after was a complete fracas.
Sherrod was forced to resign. Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack, the NAACP, and a White House painstakingly sensitive on issues of race overreacted. And many media outlets failed to do the most basic of journalistic tasks — fact check.
Fortunately, the episode appears to be resolved or close to resolution. Almost everyone has apologized, everyone except for Andrew Breitbart, who remains unrepentant. And Sherrod has a job with the Department of Agriculture if she wants it.
Breitbart was trying to make a fairly substantive point that as of late is made more and more often. His charge of reverse racism — that in many ways it is now whites who are victim to discrimination because they are white is a fear felt by many. That in the course of redressing slavery and Jim Crow we may have overreached. Policies that favor minorities such as affirmative action or efforts to promote diversity have had the effect of hurting whites, particularly working class and lower income whites.
It wouldn’t be foolish to come to the conclusion that all of these efforts have simply gone too far.
Elite universities and colleges have enrolled more African Americans and Latinos. But if you’re poor, white, and say, from Mount Pleasant, even with the best of grades you’re probably without the social connections and affiliations to go to Harvard. Economically, white working-class families were feeling pinched before this Great Recession. Economic disparity in America is returning to Gilded Age levels. Wealth continues to be concentrated at the upper echelons of society. The anxiety and grievances felt by many are real and rationally founded.
Breitbart, in his own crude way, was trying to exploit this feeling of anxiety. The video was supposed to be an example of a black federal government employee entrusted with the public’s tax dollars discriminating against an economically distressed white farmer. And gloating about it! Imagine that.
We now know the full 43-minute speech given by Sherrod tells a very different story. She ended up helping the farmer save his farm. It became apparent to her that it was poverty and class that was the larger evil. And that is the most instructive aspect of this entire ordeal and of Sherrod’s story.
Race still matters. Overt acts of racial discrimination are rare, but race still looms large in ways known and unknown in American society. Even in Iowa, where African Americans make up such a small percentage of the population, they are incarcerated at the most disproportionate rate in the country. Barriers and discrimination are still very real.
But class matters as well. Addressing racism is not a zero-sum game. The advancement of African Americans and other minority groups has not come at the expense of whites. The anxiety felt by many working and lower-income whites is an anxiety shared with all people struggling economically. Our real task is to provide greater opportunities for all people.
I don’t even know if we can have a national conversation about race. You know, that long awaited, highly anticipated cathartic-esque dialogue on race in American society. I don’t mean to suggest that we are a nation of “cowards” when it comes to race. Coward isn’t quite the right word. And despite everyone’s best wishes, we are not post-racial, either. But if the Shirley Sherrod incident teaches us anything, it’s that we definitely need to start talking about race and class.