E-books, iBooks, digital books, the Kindle and the Nook are some of the latest ways to replace page-turning physical books.
Effusive praise has been heaped on both e-readers by critics worldwide, but the question remains: are they easy to read?
The Nielsen Norman Group, a consulting firm based in Fremont, Calif. recently conducted a usability survey for both the iPad and the Kindle.
“We had subjects read short stories on the devices,” said Hoa Loranger, director at the Nielsen Norman Group.
The study found that reading speeds declined by 6.2 percent on the iPad and 10.7 percent on the Kindle compared to print. However, Loranger said the differences in reading speed between the two devices were not statistically significant because not enough information is known about either device.
Nonetheless, the study shows that traditional reading is faster than using an electronic reader. And it’s much faster than reading on a computer screen, which slows down the process by about 25 percent.
“I like reading on my iPad because it’s so interactive,” said Colton Chojnacki, a junior engineering technology major at Texas A&M U. “You can highlight a word and look up its definition while you’re reading, you can bookmark multiple places, you can even write notes.”
Still, many people prefer traditional books because of the sentimental value — the fact that they’re holding a portion of history in their hands.
“I love walking into a person’s house and seeing all the books on their shelves,” said
Elizabeth Brumbaugh, a Texas A&M finance graduate student. “We’re losing pieces of the past the further along with technology we go.” Brumbaugh has books passed down from her grandfather and said she values these curios of family history.
Lauren Brooks, a junior biology major at A&M, said she appreciates the Kindle for its functionality but would prefer an e-reader in certain situations.
“My dad travels for a lot for work and has a Kindle,” Brooks said. “He loves it because he can load all the books he wants on something that’s smaller than his laptop. I’d be fine if we went to e-books for pleasure reading, but I’d never want to have a textbook in that form.”
Not all students are interested in the possibilities of e-readers.
“I’ve never used an iPad or a Kindle,” said Melanie Starling, an A&M junior marketing major. “I’m really happy with just reading normally.”
Regardless of personal preference, electronic readers are here, and they’re here to stay.
“I think that the results from the study show that the future for e-books is very bright,” Loranger said. “Technology is getting better, screen resolution is getting more refined and prices are being reduced.