Advisory Council Releases Campus Athletics Report

By Emma Anderson

After months of scrutiny focused on the U. California-Berkeley Department of Intercollegiate Athletics’ history of overexpenditures, an analysis released Monday by faculty and alumni turns attention to Chancellor Robert Birgeneau to make the final decisions on how to pull the department away from its financially wayward past.

The analysis was conducted by an advisory council of four faculty and four alumni representatives directed by Birgeneau in March to suggest how campus intercollegiate athletics can become more financially sustainable.

These recommendations include increasing efforts to garner donations, imposing spending caps, leading a nationwide campaign against an athletics “arms race” and whittling down the amount of campus support to intercollegiate athletics to $5 million by 2014.

Now, with the submission of the advisory council’s report, along with a faculty task force’s June 12 interim report – to be expanded by fall semester – it is up to Birgeneau to give a final say on a plan for the department’s future, which could include cuts to teams, personnel and the entire scope of the athletics program.

The department has received millions of dollars in campus support for decades – about $13.7 million in 2008-09 alone. Revelation of these subsidies, exacerbated by campuswide budget cuts, spurred a Nov. 5 resolution passed by the campus division of the Academic Senate, urging Birgeneau to end support to the department and the formulation of the faculty task force. Birgeneau later created the advisory council, much to the disapproval of many resolution signatories.

Signatories said the council’s report strays away from its original message of ending all campus subsides.

“Although I am gratified to see that our efforts put the wheels in motion, the report’s recommendation to reduce the annual bailout of overspending to $5 million by 2014 is a far cry from imposing self-sufficiency,” said Brian Barsky, co-author of the resolution and professor of computer science. “It disregards both shared governance and UC policy.”

Others said the council’s report is too “sympathetic” to athletics. The report states that “some of the (department’s) significant unanticipated shortfalls … represent drops in revenue stemming from the worst economic conditions in decades” and emphasizes the role of athletics as the “window on the university,” adding to campus “spirit.”

At the same time, the analysis acknowledges the department’s “lack of budgetary controls.”

“(Other) units are not allowed to run deficits,” the report states. “Campus has suffered physically … in real threats to the ability of the faculty, staff and students to learn and to work, such as the 63 chronic roof leaks, one gardener left to mow lawns for the entire campus and antiquated laboratory facilities.”

The report emphasizes the way the department conducts finances. There was much confusion last year about language used in the department’s reporting of the total cost to campus.

Both the task force and the advisory council noted one reason the department overspent in 2008-09 was because it did not realize it was running in the red until too late in the year.

“The explosion of controllable and semi-controllable costs in IA, especially in coach and staff payroll, makes it clear that IA has been playing by a very different set of budgetary rules from the rest of campus,” the report states.

The council recommends improving accounting methods, for example, by renaming campus funding “scholarship support” for non-revenue sports to make the funding’s purpose clearer.

Emphasizing the importance of securing more donations, the report proposes hiring a development director as well as increasing fundraising efforts by coaches and teams. The idea behind this kind of “philanthropy,” according to the report, is that donors to athletics also donate to academics.

The report states that the most prominent athletics supporters have “collectively given $280 million to athletics – and $370 million to academics … (demonstrating) that fund-raising efforts for both academics and athletics are ‘bound at the hip.'”

However, Vicki De Goff, an alumna and donor to the campus who has pledged $100,000 to a Boalt Hall School of Law program, said campus support to athletics has negatively impacted her future donation plans.

“When I finish paying that pledge, I’m not giving another cent to the university because … (it) is spending too much money on athletics,” she said.

In a response letter to the report, Birgeneau said he will make decisions by the beginning of the fall semester, based on the analyses from both the advisory council and the task force.

Athletic Director Sandy Barbour said the department has already begun making necessary cuts, planning for a $2.4 million budget reduction this coming year, eliminating 22 positions and reducing both travel costs and the recruitment of players.

“Athletics hasn’t been sitting around waiting for this report,” Barbour said. “Or for the task force or even necessarily for the chancellor to make some ultimate financial model decision.”

Read more here: http://www.dailycal.org/article/109839/advisory_council_releases_campus_athletics_report
Copyright 2026 Daily Californian