Prosecutors dropped a misdemeanor furnishing alcohol charge against Alpha Tau Omega (ATO) Tuesday in connection to Joseph Dado’s death — leaving the fraternity with one lingering misdemeanor charge that could see a conclusion within a month.
ATO attorney Kathleen Yurchak said prosecutors dropped a misdemeanor charge against the fraternity for furnishing alcohol to Penn State student Dado and three of his friends on the night of his death.
Judge Thomas Kistler did not offer a verdict on the second charge of misdemeanor unlawful acts relative to liquor, malt and brewed beverages and licenses, but is expected to issue a written decision in as early as a month, Yurchak said.
The second charge, which Kistler has not yet ruled on, doesn’t specify a person needs to knowingly furnish the alcohol to be convicted, according to court documents.
No more evidence can be submitted at this point, she said, and the case will continue only through briefs written and submitted by both parties.
The two-day search for the Penn State student concluded when Dado, 18, was found dead in a stairwell between the Steidle and Hosler Buildings on Sept. 21, 2009.
Dado visited ATO, 321 E. Fairmount Ave., and Phi Gamma Delta (Fiji), 319 N. Burrowes Rd., before falling to his death across the street from the Fiji house, police said.
Dado, of Latrobe, Pa., had a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.169 percent — more than twice the legal limit for a 21-year-old to drive, police said.
Yurchak said she expected the furnishing charges against ATO to be dropped because the facts of the case cleared the fraternity from any wrongdoing on that count.
“That’s simply what the facts were from day one,” she said. “Fraternities are made to be fall guys in these situations.”
ATO National Fraternity did not return calls for comment.
County prosecutor Nathan Boob did not return calls for comment by press time Wednesday.
ATO was originally charged under both the Pennsylvania Criminal Code and the Pennsylvania Liquor Code laws with furnishing alcohol to minors, according to court documents.
The Pennsylvania Criminal Code specifies that a person must “intentionally and knowingly” furnish alcohol to a minor to be convicted, according to court documents.
Yurchak said she argued in court that ATO never knowingly furnished alcohol to minors, which is why prosecutors dropped that charge, she said.
The two original charges brought against ATO are so similar in their language, Yurchak said, that if the prosecution could not prove one of the charges she believes they will not be able to prove the other.
Kistler did not return calls for comment by press time Wednesday.
A trial date for Fiji has been set for Aug. 2, according to court documents.
A trial date for Penn State student Jack Townsend, also charged with furnishing alcohol to Dado, is set for later in the summer, according to court documents.