It appears that the fate of a new Museum of Art is once again fraught with doubt. The Daily Iowan Editorial Board was seriously concerned when it was reported that the Federal Emergency Management Agency denied U. Iowa replacement funds for a building in a new location. UI officials are now appealing to FEMA. Whether the UI campus and community is able to once again house a Museum of Art may largely depend on whether FEMA reverses its decision.
The Editorial Board certainly hopes FEMA rethinks its decision. The rationale for denying the UI funds for a new building was made on rather dubious grounds. According to FEMA rules, flooding must have caused more than 50 percent of the damage to the building. Determining the damage caused to the Art Museum failed to meet this threshold, FEMA denied the university funds to build a new museum elsewhere. FEMA also requires the UI to obtain appropriate insurance to protect against future loss and damage as well. All of this seems reasonable thus far.
There is a logical argument against this: The Art Museum was sitting on a floodplain. If the building was rebuilt there, serious damage in future flooding is more than probable. It makes sense that the museum’s insurer would no longer provide coverage for the art collection in this scenario, which is the case.
Certainly, there has to be some malleability to the guidelines FEMA has set out. The UI simply can’t return its art collection to its current location and have it insured. Rebuilding the museum in its old location would not only result in a loss of its insurer, it would also lose its accreditation from the National Association of Museums. This would be a serious blow to the reputation and stature of the museum.
If FEMA rejects the UI’s appeal, funds to build a new museum would most likely have to be raised from private donors. This would involve some extremely heavy lifting for the university. And it could be a significant setback, delaying planning and construction of a building and in the hiring of a new director. It’s unthinkable at this point, but without FEMA funds, the UI and Iowa City could be without a new museum in the foreseeable future.
It is encouraging, however, that the planning committee tasked with finding a new site is continuing its work.
Museums add cultural richness and vibrancy to communities. They allow us to explore and appreciate classic art as well as contemporary art. Museums on college campuses are also used to enrich the classroom experience. UI art majors who have taken classes or spent time in the Art Museum know this firsthand.
For all the above stated reasons and many more, the DIEditorial Board encourages FEMA to grant the UI replacement funds for the construction of a new Art Museum. The Art Museum has one of the finest art collections in the Midwest, and the UI and the greater Iowa City community has been hurt by its absence.