Spokane police administrators claim that mentally disabled Otto Zehm used a two-liter bottle of soda as a weapon and lunged at an officer who approached him in a convenience store. Zehm was assaulted by two police officers, struck with a police baton at least six times and shocked three times with Tasers. Then, he was rendered unconscious, hogtied and placed in a plastic mask. He died two days later on March 20, 2006.
However, video recordings show Zehm used his soda bottle to protect his head from the officers’ batons, not as a weapon. Further investigation also revealed that Zehm committed no crime whatsoever. He was a victim of circumstance, and a casualty of a notoriously brutal police system that needs to be reformed.
Recently, the question of Spokane police brutality has been re-raised in troubling detail.
Pacific Northwest Inlander reporter Nicholas Deshais cites case after case in which Spokane police officers were too willing to use a baton, a Taser and even a gun in his June 29 article, “Strong Arm of the Law.” It is clear that “shoot first, ask questions later” is not effective policing.
In the last five years, there have been 95 complaints of excessive force against the Spokane County Sheriff’s Office. For example, a small group of anarchists held a peaceful protest against police brutality in Spokane’s Riverfront Park, July 4, 2007. They, too, became victims of police brutality when the protest broke into a riot. Though they violated no laws, 17 protesters were arrested, according to the Spokesman-Review.
It is unfortunate that this constitutionally protected protest was illegally stifled, particularly when it was needed so much.
Zehm’s death has prompted some policy reforms, but not enough. Two obvious changes Spokane must make is to give more power to the ombudsman and make internal affairs rulings public record, like many other cities in the state have already done.
Deshais writes, “Between 2005 and 2009, Spokane Police investigated 55 complaints of excessive force, and in only one case did the Internal Affairs detectives sustain the allegations.” These records, however, are not made public.
In a guest commentary to the Spokesman-Review, former Spokane City Council Member Al French said, “Whether it’s the investigation … of the tragic death of Otto Zehm or the sex offender living in the basement of a Spokane police officer, the manner in which the city chooses to inform, or in most cases not inform, the community creates an atmosphere of distrust.”
The reluctance of the city council and the office of the mayor to empower the new police ombudsman position is worrisome. The ombudsman office is currently not a full-time position, despite previous plans, and remains unable to question officers directly.
Breean Beggs, executive director the Spokane nonprofit group Center for Justice, said cities with full-time ombudsmen save government money because they have “fewer injuries, fewer deaths and fewer claims,” in an interview with the Spokesman-Review.
Police officers are heroes, meant to help protect people who cannot protect themselves — people like Otto Zehm. Bad cops dishonor the badge they wear and everything they stand for. They should be purged not protected.