Rating: 6
While “It Follows” could be considered a step in the right direction for a new generation of horror movies, it ultimately offers a flawed and somewhat dragging plot.
The film is about Jay, a girl in her late teens played by Maika Monroe who lives in a suburban neighborhood with quirky friends and without much of a care in the world. Everything seems great for her until after she hooks up with this new guy she’s been dating — Hugh, played by Jake Weary. After capturing her and explaining to her that a curse has just been passed from him to her, Hugh warns that something that can look like any person will be following her the rest of her life, and what’s worse, she’s the only one who can see it. Now in a fight for her sanity and life, Jay and her friends must find a way to undo the curse brought upon her and get rid of the thing that follows.
Starting with the positives: “It Follows” director and screenplay writer David Robert Mitchell had a pretty good idea with the film’s plot as an ever-changing creepy face that follows an increasingly desperate subject whom no one believes is sane, is a disturbing concept to say the least. The idea that a horrible curse could be passed from person to person is of course nothing new, but the idea that the “follower” can take the form of any person is an intriguing idea. This opens the possibility for many different kinds of scares, rather than the typical overused jump-scare that almost every modern horror movie has beaten to death at this point. A particular scene in the film that captured the extremely creepy vibe that this film is targeting, is when Jay is sitting in a classroom and sees an old woman in a hospital gown out the window, walking straight toward her from across campus. This was a great taste for how the movie would present its scares: slowly but surely.
Another positive that could be taken away from seeing this film was the camera work. Since this was classified as a horror movie, “It Follows” took most people by surprise, especially film nerds, when the audience was presented with camera work that was reminiscent of an art house flick. There were 360-degree shots in multiple scenes, as well as fantastic camera angles that were able to capture the feel of the scene, with a touch of subtlety and finesse.
Now that the credit has been given where its due, it’s time to discuss what made this film disappointing. While some of the plot was indeed a unique and clever idea, there were aspects of it that detracted from the finished product as a whole. Most notably, the way the curse was passed between people: by having sex. This alone made the movie not scary. This is where the movie went from being a creepy horror film, to a film that students get shown in health class. With this being a major point of the plot throughout the movie, a more appropriate title would’ve been “Ghost Herpes.” If there was some kind of mystery as to why the subjects were being followed, instead of just blatantly saying “because sex” at the beginning of the movie, it would make the events that much creepier, because no one would know why these weird things were happening. The idea that the following might have randomly been assigned to an individual regardless of character, would’ve worked better in terms of the scare factor. However, it is also important to acknowledge that many modern audiences have come to expect explanations for any movie plot points. This is fine, but sex as an explanation for a horror film just doesn’t cut it.
More aspects of the film that didn’t quite work were the pacing of the plot as well as the overall feel of the film. The plot takes its time in this movie, a behavior much like the thing that follows. It doesn’t run, it doesn’t move quickly, it walks. While this approach is normally a great one to take, as too many horror films tend to rush through things like character development and story, the plot in this movie started to drag about halfway through. When people in the audience start checking the time on their phones during what is supposed to be the climax of the film, it means the film has lost its audience, either because it’s gone on for too long, the things that are happening aren’t all that interesting, or both. In this case, it was both. The film’s run time is an hour and 47 minutes.
Despite this relatively normal run time, the movie feels like it’s two and a half hours. This is due, in part, to the pacing of the film’s plot. It seemed like the events that were most gripping happened earlier in the film. As the movie wears on, the subject matter takes a shift from a horror film to a young adult film. This is where Jay’s character starts to have conflicting feelings for her quirky friend Paul, played by Keir Gilchrist, and it starts to focus on their love for eachother. While character development is good for any movie, the pacing at which these feelings were developed seemed odd and some of the scenes between the two characters didn’t seem relevant to the overall story arch.
While “It Follows” has some encouragingly unique ideas as to what a horror movie can be, its overall performance was a bit underwhelming. For audiences looking to have a good scare at the theater, you will find a few in this film, but as an overall experience, it may be worth waiting to watch on Netflix.